Bonner: "America- Love it Or Leave It"

More From The Mobile Register   |   Subscribe To The Mobile Register
Bonner remark raises eyebrows
Monday, March 28, 2005
Editor's note: "The Political Skinny" is an inside look at Alabama politics prepared by the staff of the Mobile Register. The column is compiled by Political Editor Jim Van Anglen, who can be reached at :jvananglen@mobileregister.com or 251-219-5608.

During "town hall" meetings in Baldwin County last week, U.S. Rep. Jo Bonner, R-Mobile, most likely expected tough questions about President Bush's Social Security proposal.

But the congressman probably did not anticipate that several constituents at his stop in Gulf Shores would spend much of the hour-long meeting criticizing his support of the Iraq war.

To make his case, Bonner recounted his experience traveling to Iraq and hearing horror stories about Saddam Hussein. The congressman also visited the dictator's torture chambers. He said that although some of the reasons for invading Iraq may have turned out to be off-base, the end result -- Iraq's first free elections -- made the endeavor worthwhile.

None of this satisfied the critics, who said the war was a waste of lives and money. Bonner then said: "The great thing about this country is if you don't like it, you can leave."

That comment drew gasps from the audience, some from those who had told the congressman they agreed with his position on Iraq.

One woman asked, "Excuse me?"

Bonner quickly redacted his remark, saying that he meant no offense, nor that his anti-war constituents in south Baldwin County should pack their bags. It was intended to mean that citizens in a democracy have options not open to those under totalitarian rule, Bonner said.

"My point was not to offend anybody," he said. "My point was that if we don't like something, we can change it peacefully."

________________

I think the "America: Love it or Get the Hell out" will be a marvelous campaign slogan for Congressman Bonner. It's catchy. Don't ya think? Bonner was re-elected with 63% of the vote last cycle, wouldn't it be sweet if we knocked him off?



Display:


I think that's a great idea (none / 0)

I certainly hope the Democrats are smart enough to pick up on it. I'm still waiting for signs of life from the Democratic party. They seem to still be on life support, with little hope for recovery as a hard hitting political party.

What's the harshest criticism any Democrat has made against President Bush? What's the harshest criticism any Democrat has made against any Republican?

by Gary Boatwright on Mon Mar 28, 2005 at 10:33:55 AM EST

Re: I think that's a great idea (none / 0)

For example, Bilmon calls the Republican party an infectious disease. Look at all the dispicable things De Lay says about Democrats.

Now try to come up with anything that would be considered even a little bit rude or even marginally objectionable that any Democrat has said against any Republican since Bush's inauguration.

Why are the Democrats acting like a bunch of French poodles in a fight with Republican pit bulls?

by Gary Boatwright on Mon Mar 28, 2005 at 10:38:07 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: I think that's a great idea (none / 0)

My personal opinion is because they are stinging from the election. They may be saying "Look guys, we lost. The people decided. Our guy lost by 3.5 million votes, we lost seats in the Senate, we lost seats in the House. If we attack this President, we'll end up suffering"

My personal thought. The party has to present a direct alternative in order to show America that there is a second choice. I don't even think the party is trying to move to the center, I just think they are just winging it by being reactive instead of proactive.

by falcon4e on Mon Mar 28, 2005 at 11:28:17 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: I think that's a great idea (none / 0)

Actually, the Democrats are taking a page from the John Kerry 2004 playbook, "Vote for me because I'm not the other guy". That rarely works overall, and it never works when the other guy's sole claim to fame is standing for something. (Not that you like what he's standing for, just that he stands for something)
ELijah Mohammed's more famous quotes talks about how if all you offer the people is a polluted glass of water, they will drink it, in the absence of a better alternative.

The Democrats need to be a better alternative to the oil-polluted water of George Bush.

Falcon4e: Please shoot me a email when you get a chance, as I would like to hear your opinion on a few things offline:    xodus1914@ureach.com

by Bruticus on Fri May 06, 2005 at 09:19:48 AM EST
[ Parent ]

I don't think that the Dems have much to be ashame (none / 0)

After all, the Dems are standing up for people, not like the GOP who are pursuing a strictly corporate agenda..

The only thing that (some of them) screwed up on is voting with the pro-bank Republicans to pass the terrible legalized loan-sharking - ugh, 'bankruptcy' bill..

actually, thats a biggie.. maybe I should take that back.. some of them have a lot to be ashamed of..

Read this essay on its implications, 'Broke'

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/27/magazine/27WWLN.html?pagewanted=all&position=

by ultraworld on Mon Mar 28, 2005 at 12:55:13 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.